DC Cinematic Universe

DC Cinematic Universe Fantasies

 By Mitchell A. Quondam

As a follow up to my fantasy-driven post about Batman in the DC Cinematic Universe, I had the idea to map out how I would advance the story, introducing new characters to the Universe and building up to big events like Marvel does. In this post, I cover the entire Universe, and give my thoughts on how WB/DC should go about their shared universe going onward

Confirmed Cast of Heroes:

Henry Cavill as Kal-El

Ben Affleck as Batman

Stephen Amell as The Arrow

Ryan Reynolds as Hal Jordan

Grant Gustin as Barry Allen

Wishlist

Gina Carano as Wonder Woman

Benedict Cumberbatch as Martian Manhunter*

Idris Elba as John Stewart

Garrett Hedlund as Aquaman

Joseph Gordon-Levit as Nightwing

Chris Pine or Matt Bomer as Tim Drake, the Red Robin

*Martian Manhunter being played by Cumberbatch is not whitewashing the character. He is green, and only pretends to be a black guy as a ploy. I would actually prefer if he didn’t try to blend in at all, and just stay green the entire film.

 

Major Production Players:

Zack Snyder – Man of Steel/Justice League Director and Universe Overseer

Christopher Nolan – Executive Producer

Guillermo del Toro – Director of Dark Universe and others

Ben Affleck – Director of solo Batman films

Phase 1 (2011-2015)

•                     Green Lantern 2011 (Introduces Hal Jordan, Sinestro, Star Saphire)

•                     Man of Steel (Introduces Superman, Lois, General Zod)

•                     Man of Steel 2/Batman Vs. Superman (Introduces Batman, Lex Luthor)

•                     Arrow TV Series (Introduces Green Arrow, Flash, Deathstroke and several villains)

            Big Event: Justice League (Introduces Wonder Woman, John Stewart, Martian Manhunter)

 

Phase 2 (2015-2017)

•                     Batman Solo Movie (Introduces Joker, and Tim Drake's Robin)

•                     Flash TV Series (Introduces Cyborg and some lesser known heroes and villains)

•                     Arrow TV Series (Introduces Black Canary as a hero)

•                     Man of Steel 3 (Introduces Aquaman, Supergirl, Bizarro)

•                     Dark Universe (Introduces Constantine, Swamp Thing, Zatanna)

           Big Event: Justice League 2 (Introduces a big villain, possibly Brainiac or Darkseid)

Phase 3 (2017-2020)

•                     Nightwing (Introduces Two-Face, Harley Quinn and Duela Dent)

•                     Batman 2 (Introduces The Court of Owls, Batgirl/Oracle)

•                     Arrow series finale, Flash is still on for now

•                     Green Lantern 2 (Introduces Red Lantern corps.)

          Big Event: Sinestro Corps. War

Bonus Phase: Movies I want but will never see

•                     Secret Six

•                     Deathstroke Origin Movie

•                     Any Villain Origin Movie (Mainly Joker and Bane)

•                     Shazam or Captain Marvel

•                     Injustice: Gods Among Us

•                     The Spectre

*All Images are from deviantart

Batman in the New DC Cinematic Universe

DC Cinematic Universe: Batman

A Blog by Mitchell A. Quondam

With the release of Man of Steel, and the announcement that its sequel will feature The Dark Knight, I recently became very excited about the idea of a “DC Cinematic Universe” similar to what Marvel has done at their studio in conjunction with Disney. Unlike Marvel Studios, Warner Brothers retains the rights to all DC characters, from the classic heroes such as Batman and Superman, to lesser known heroes like Cyborg and the Spectre, to separate universes like The Watchmen. WB and DC have a near-unlimited pool of resources to pull characters and story arcs, and yet, until now, they haven’t utilized them properly. We haven’t seen the long fabled Justice League movie, many of the second tier heroes underperform (Watchmen, Green Lantern, Constantine) or are just plain bad (Jonah Hex, Supergirl, Steel).

However things are rapidly changing. Under the trust and creative control of Zack Snyder and to a lesser extent Christopher Nolan, the DC Universe is starting to take form. Man of Steel started the universe, a universe which Batman exists in (and Cyborg and Aquaman if throwaway Easter Eggs in Man of Steel are to be believed). Eventually Batman will get his own solo movie, and there is also a movement in WB to connect Arrow (Which introduced Huntress, Deathstroke and soon the Flash) into the movie universe, possibly with a Flash TV series or solo film.

This particular entry, however, is all about Batman. I will quickly list my dream casting for the major supporting characters, and some ideas about which directions they should take with Batman (and the Bat Family)

Batman Dream Casting

Bruce/Batman –Ben Affleck

Joker – Benedict Cumberbatch, Sam Rockwell, Christopher Eccleston

Riddler – David Tenant, Johnny Depp, David Hyde Pierce (as an older Riddler maybe?)

Mister Freeze – John Malkovich, Ed Harris, Sir Ben Kingsley, a bald Harrison Ford, Ralph Fiennes

Alfred - Timothy Dalton, David Hyde Pierce

Catwoman – Rachel Weisz, Kate Beckinsale

Harley Quinn – Kristen Bell, Helena Bonham Carter

Penguin – Phillip Seymour Hoffman

Jim Gordon – Kurt Russell, Michael Keaton

Hugo Strange – Sir Ben Kingsley, Hugo Weaving, Bryan Cranston

Robin/Red Hood – Jensen Ackles

Hush – Eric Bana, Jude Law

Bane – Javier Bardem

Poison Ivy – Eva Green (No Pun Intended) Cate Blanchett

Okay, now that that is out of the way, I feel the need to mention that not all of those listed are “main villains” which goes into the first item on my wishlist

Villain Cameos

If you have ever read the Long Halloween, Dark Victory, or Hush, then you know that the idea of villain cameos isn’t new. The Dark Knight and Dark Knight Rises actually did this to a lesser extent with Scarecrow, but I’m thinking a little bigger. Under Snyder, the DC Universe has a sense of surrealism to it, similar in flavor to the Arkham Video Games, and there is no reason why we can’t have a simple, say, Poison Ivy, or Calendar Man cameo just to get some plot information out in an interesting way.

Court of Owls

I didn’t put any cast members down for this, but it is something that I feel needs to be covered in film. One of the popular complaints is that this arc doesn’t feature a major villain, and people won’t flock to see it. To that I respond, once you put “Batman” in the title, you already have the cash of the casual cinema-goer in your pocket. Court of Owls was a compelling story, and can introduce a new villain into the mainstream, similar to what Nolan’s trilogy did for Ra’s al Ghul and his daughter Talia.

                          Batman Family

Batman doesn’t need 15 year old kids following him around, but it could be arranged that they are in their early twenties and have become somewhat autonomous, acting without Batman, but still coming to his aid and following orders. This is also and “older, wearier” Batman, and there is a possibility that he has already trained several other heroes who are also out on the prowl, such as Nightwing, Red Robin (Tim Drake) and Batgirl (Barbara Gordon or Cassandra Cain). Oracle (if they go that route) could also replace Lucius Fox as Caped Crusader’s computer/gadgetry expert, opening up a new dynamic not seen yet in live-action Batman.

Using Batman as a Platform

Man of Steel 2 has essentially become Batman vs. Superman. Batman would be a good way to bring in some street-level superheroes, such as the previously mentioned Bat-Family, and film versions of Green Arrow, Black Canary and Huntress, who have all teamed up with Batman in the past (In one continuity, Huntress is the child of batman and Catwoman, and Green Arrow was originally an idea for a second Batman sidekick)

Marvel Cinematic Universe

Marvel Cinematic Universe

An Informative Essay by

Mitchell A. Quondam

The Marvel Cinematic Universe is a film franchise and shared fictional universe that is the setting of superhero films independently produced by Marvel Studios, based on characters that appear in publications by Marvel Comics. The shared universe of the films, much like the Marvel Universe in comic books, was established by crossing over common plot elements, settings, cast, and characters.
The entire continuity is produced by Kevin Fiege. Fiege said in April 2010 that constructing a shared film universe:

“...is daunting but it's fun. It's never been done before and that's kind of the spirit everybody's taking it in. The other filmmakers aren't used to getting actors from other movies that other filmmakers have cast, certain plot lines that are connected or certain locations that are connected, but I think ... everyone was on board for it and thinks that it's fun. Primarily because we've always remained consistent saying that the movie that we are making comes first. All of the connective tissue, all of that stuff is fun and is going to be very important if you want it to be. If the fans want to look further and find connections, then they're there. There are a few big ones obviously, that hopefully the mainstream audience will able to follow as well. But ... the reason that all the filmmakers are on board is that their movies need to stand on their own. They need to have a fresh vision, a unique tone, and the fact that they can interconnect if you want to follow those breadcrumbs is a bonus”

The first step of the Universe, titled Phase 1, was to set up an Avengers movie by introducing the members in individual films with a single cast. The first of these was Iron Man, starring Robert Downey Jr. in the titular role, which began the Avengers Initiative with a cameo from Nick Fury (Samuel L. Jackson). Next was the Incredible Hulk played by Edward Norton, which was tied to Iron Man with a cameo by Robert Downey Jr. Iron Man 2 heavily featured members of S.H.I.E.L.D, a popular group in the Marvel Universe, and, along with Nick Fury, added Scarlett Johansson as the Black Widow. Thor featured Nick Fury, Agent Coulson (played by Clark Gregg, who appeared in Iron Man and its sequel) and Hawkeye, played by Jeremy Renner. Lastly, Captain America (played by Chris Evans) featured Fury, and a plot device from Thor called the Tesseract (known in the comics as the Cosmic Cube) and ended with the first teaser for the Avengers. The next Step is Phase 2, a series that will introduce the Avengers 2. Phase 3 has been announced, and will feature new heroes Ant-Man, Doctor Strange, and possibly a new Hulk film.



People Involved
Directors/Producers
Kevin Fiege - Producer
Jon Favreau –Director (Iron Man 1&2)
Shane Black – Director (Iron Man 3)
Joe Johnston – Director (Captain America: The First Avenger)
Louis Leterrier – Director (Incredible Hulk)
Joss Whedon – Director (The Avengers/Avengers 2)
Edgar Wright – Director (Ant-Man)
Kenneth Branagh – Director (Thor)
Alan Taylor – Director (Thor: The Dark World)
James Gunn – Director (Guardians of the Galaxy)
Anthony & Joe Russo – Directors (Captain America: the Winter Soldier)

Cast
Iron Man – Robert Downey jr.
Thor – Chris Hemsworth
Captain America – Chris Evans
Bruce Banner/Hulk – Mark Ruffalo (previously Edward Norton)
Black Widow – Scarlett Johansson
Hawkeye – Jeremy Renner
Nick Fury – Samuel L. Jackson
Loki – Tom Hiddleston
War Machine –  Don Cheadle (previously Terrance Howard)
Red Skull – Hugo Weaving
Iron Monger – Jeff Bridges
Whiplash/Crimson Dynamo – Mickey Rourke
The Mandarin – Ben Kingsley
Bucky/Winter Soldier – Sebastian Stan



Released Films (In order of their release)  
Iron Man  
The Incredible Hulk  
Iron Man 2  
Thor  
Captain America  
The Avengers  

Upcoming Films (In order of their release)  
Iron Man 3  
Thor: The Dark World  
Captian America: The Winter Soldier  
Guardians of the Galaxy  
The Avengers 2  
Ant Man  
Doctor Strange  
A “Planet Hulk” film has been proposed before the release of…  
The Avengers 3


Continuity Issues 

There were only two casting issues in this continuity. The first was an Iron Man character named Rhodey AKA War Machine. Originally played by Terrance Howard, was replaced by Don Cheadle for Iron Man 2, and Cheadle will reprise his role in the future. The second recast was the Hulk. Edward Norton left the project and was replaced with Mark Ruffalo for the Avengers. For now, Ruffalo is also set to reprise his role in Avengers 2.

One of the issues often discussed is that Marvel does not own all of its products at the moment. Spider-Man currently resides at Sony, and Fox owns X-Men and Fantastic Four rights at the moment. This deal includes all of their villains. This causes issues as many heroes have common enemies. For example, Iron Man and Spider-Man both have Norman Osborn as a villain. In the comics he retired the Green Goblin moniker and rebranded himself Iron Patriot, and was a popular Iron Man villain for a long time. Likewise, Fantastic Four villain Galactus is an occasional foe of the Avengers.

In October 2012, Lauren Shuler Donner, the producer of 20th Century Fox's X-Men film series, expressed interest in having the X-Men characters appear in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Shuler Donner said, "I would love it. I personally have close ties to Marvel because of Kevin Feige, because Kevin worked for me. But to take our characters and mingle them in the way that they were written, yeah, absolutely." Mark Millar, who was hired in September 2012 to consult on all of Fox's future Marvel films, expressed similar sentiments in an interview, saying "Fox have said that they want to build a cohesive universe and I’d personally like this to work in complement to the Marvel one. It would be cool if these universes didn’t contradict each other so if you went to see Spidey, The Avengers, the X-Men, etc, as a viewer you would have no idea that all three are coming from different studios. I’d love to make it look like they’re all just happening in one place."

A minor crossover almost took place in the Avengers. Marvel Studios got permission from Sony Pictures to use the Oscorp building, a major location form the Amazing Spider-Man franchise. The building would have appeared in the skyline of Marvel’s New York, but unfortunately the rendering of the skyline was completed before the Oscorp building was out of the design stage. Also, as of October 2012, there are currently works of a short-term trade, where Fox will briefly hold the rights to Daredevil, and in return Marvel Studios receives the rights to Galactus and the Silver Surfer.

When Marc Webb, director of the Amazing Spider-Man was asked about expanding his Spider-Man universe over the course of several Spider-Man related movies, he replied “Think bigger” leading many to believe that he is trying to tie his Spider-Man, played by Andrew Garfield, into the Marvel Universe.

Proposals by Marvel

The following films have been proposed by Marvel, but have not begun writing or production yet:


Black Panther        Power Pack  
Cable                 Ka-Zar  
Heroes for Hire   Iron Fist  
Luke Cage solo Nighthawk  
Daredevil reboot Vision  
Cloak and Dagger Doctor Strange  
Dazzler

The Dark Knight Rises Review

A Blog by

Mitchell A. Quondam

 

The best thing about this movie is how satisfying it is. It doesn't leave you frustrated or confused. You can't really complain that it didn't explore certain ideas or follow through. By deciding to have an official ending to this trilogy's story, the themes surrounding Batman are very fresh. We don't know where he'll end up. It's not the same old thing about whether he can continue to be Batman or not. The conclusions are not as important as the feelings they invoke as they come about. Nolan is especially good at capturing the complete tension of actually not knowing what will happen and deeply questioning what you want to happen and why.

This movie is bigger than the previous two, far more ambitious. There are no obvious annoying weaknesses that usually come with films in general, especially blockbuster action movies. All of Nolan's movies have deep psychological themes and this takes those in another new direction. I thought Inception was hugely original and insightful about the way people think. That level of abstraction and depth is present in this film. Bane bursts into it, his reputation is quickly established. Nolan uses people's expectations and anticipation to the fullest. We are left to wonder about what has happened in the 8 years since the events of The Dark Knight. Why have the characters become the way they are now?

In the latter half, it does seem like the movie is trying to pull off so many different plot points and connections, but they all work. The cast is very large and impressive. You don't see "good acting". You see fascinating characters. They're just playing their part in the grand story that's being crafted. There are many unfamiliar faces but they all have a strange, unique look to them. We often see a person's flaws and previous decisions coming back to haunt them. They find out the hard way what mistakes they have made, where their limits are, where they lose control.

The score is almost tribal, very raw and energetic. You don't get much chance to pay attention to it but many parts of the movie are pounding with excitement. There are countless quotable lines and disturbing slices of dialogue. They cut deep. The Joker was a great character and this is a very different movie but the themes are just as dark, only perhaps indirectly. Underneath, it's very sinister. Writing and efficiency appear to be among Nolan's greatest strengths. The story has many layers that interweave and apparently they came in under budget.

The Visual effects were equally impressive.

Perhaps the most important thing about Catwoman is that she's completely believable. When she beats up men, you don't roll your eyes. She's feminine and powerful in her own way. She fits into the world and we completely understand her motivations. She doesn't have a huge role but a very important one.

I thought Christian Bale was overlooked in The Dark Knight especially. The movies hinge on him. Bruce Wayne's just a man but also incredibly inspirational. Bale's famous for completely committing to his roles and it pays off. Tom Hardy is impressive as Bane but I suppose that's no surprise. The rest of the leads are similarly awesome. There are many references to the earlier films. Very few questions are left unanswered. It's always nice when film-makers really think it through and make an actual decision and get all the details right.

My criticisms have to do with the themes of the story. Batman Begins was all about fear, doubt, self-realization and redemption where Bruce Wayne discovers his destiny as Batman. BB had a story arc which set background for main characters – Batman/ Wayne, Ra's al Ghul, Gordon and most importantly Gotham City and hence set stage for a fitting climax.

The Dark Knight explores the theme of chaos, morality and belief effortlessly and establishes characters of Joker, Harvey Dent/Two Face, Rachel etc. so effortlessly that people choose to ignore even some major plot holes. Heath Ledger's interpretation of Joker was so mesmerizing that it single handily carried TDK to path of greatness and critical acclaim.

But Dark Knight Rises is all about story telling; efficient but not exceptional. Bane, Miranda Tate, John Blake, Peter Foley, Selina Kyle are characters are introduced but never explored or expanded; they just start working on their part like cogs in the wheel. They are not so much part of the story itself but just the agents which move the story forward.

There's no dilemma, doubt, love, choices, moral battles, hope, even no chaos/fear- themes which make characters and plot interesting and which made Batman Begins and The Dark Knight really good movies. Even the theme of "Occupy Wall Street" is very weak and at best it's closer to London riots with its loot and arson. There's even perfect order in Bane's revolution. The movie moves effortlessly from one plot to another and to climax that it become at times predictable.

But maybe Dark Knight Rises was supposed to be like that only and Nolan had too much to deal with in 2.5 hours. And maybe that's the only true problem with Dark Knight Rises: too much is going on in the story that it seems crammed at times, and when there are too many characters and so many story arcs it is tough to do justice to characters and story telling at the same time. And this is when you start looking for plot holes, slackness, and predictability.

My Favourite Spider-Man Villains

My Favourite Spider-Man Villains

A Blog by

Mitchell A. Quondam

Spider-Man is my second favourite superhero (Behind Batman), and in my opinion, he has the best rogues gallery of any superhero. They could announce just about any villain to be in the next Spider-man movie and I'd be stoked. His villains have a wide variety of abilities, ranging from electricity, to transforming into an animal, to simply being an incredibly skilled hunter. One of my criticisms of Batman's rogues gallery is that, while they are all fantastic, well-developed characters, there are not many that can challenge Batman physically beyond Bane, Killer Croc and sometimes Ra's al Ghul. Spider-Man doesn't have this problem. Realistically, a B-list villain such as Rhino or Shocker offers just as much physical harm as the mainstays like Venom.

10 - Kraven the Hunter
His fanciful costume and lack of superpowers have turned many off of him, but I've always thought that he was pretty cool. The story arc in which he succeeds in killing Spider-Man also dove into the character's mentality. With the greatest prey now defeated, what does he do next? This was one of the finest arcs in the Spider-Man comics, because it was villain-centric. We are led to believe that Spidey was dead and Kraven was driven to depression, and eventually, suicide. I'm not a big fan of the heirs to Kraven's name, but the original, Sergei Kravenoff, is still awesome.

9 - The Lizard
The Lizard has always been a fan-favourite. He is one of those villains I discussed that provides a very real threat to Spider-Man. It seemed like Spidey always lost more fights against Lizard than he won. Along with being a threat, he looked very cool in all of the incarnations I can remember. A lot of people criticize the Amazing Spider-Man for taking away two Lizard signatures in his lab coat and his snout, but I forgot about those little gripes when watching the movie, and I thought that what they did worked with the story. I also think that both Rhys Ifans and Dylan Baker played the role of Curt Connors very well, although the nod has to go to Ifans, because he also got to play the lizard.

8 - Carnage
The first experience I had with Carnage was in the 2000 Spider-Man video game, and it was love at first sight. He was like a more vicious Venom. Since reading the comics and other source material, my love for the character has only grown. He was extremely dangerous even before he got the alien costume, and after, he killed more people than the Punisher and Judge Dredd combined. I have never seen a comic book character with a higher body count than Carnage.

7 - Venom
A lot of people are very high on Venom, and have him listed in the top three, but I feel he suffers from over-exposure. Ever since the original arc, he has been in every media available, even more than the Green Goblin. Besides comics, he's been on TV Shows, a live action movie (sadly), action figures, video games, including several where he is the playable character, and it would appear that he has his own stand-alone movie coming soon. Mac Gargan getting the Venom suit mixed it up a bit, but not much. I may be in the minority here, but I’m not a fan of the Flash Thompson Venom at all. It reminds me too much of Spawn for some reason.

6 - Hobgoblin
I recently went back and read the original Hobgoblin story arcs, and I was very impressed. I always liked his look more than the Green Goblin's, but he also has a great story to fall back on, and the mystery of who was behind the mask was intriguing to me. If I was to do a Spider-Man film, I would leave his identity a mystery until the very end. He would not be built up; he would just appear as a mad bomber and start wreaking havoc, until Spider-Man finally stops him at the end. Joker never needed his origin told, Nolan just threw the Joker into the mix. If Hobgoblin had the right story, he could top Green Goblin in terms of coolness.

5 - Mysterio
I like his look, and his illusions always add something unique to every battle. My criticism is that he is not truly a physical threat to Spider-Man by himself. He always needs traps or trickery on his side. However, we need not worry about that anymore as, unfortunately, he has passed away. Much like Kraven the Hunter, Mysterio has committed suicide, and we may never see Quentin Beck again in Marvel Comics.

4 - Scorpion
One of Spider-Man's earliest villains, Scorpion was always a favourite of mine. I liked his look, his powers and his character. In most continuities, he doesn't even want to be a villain, but is prompted to by either J. Jonah Jameson or Norman Osborn. He was an outcast, and after his first couple issues only wanted to steal enough money to get out of the suit. He has also appeared in many mediums, but I am still looking forward to finally seeing Scorpion on the big screen.

3 - Doctor Octopus
I've always liked Doctor Octopus. My first experience of him was in reruns of the 1967 Spider-Man, and back then he was my second favourite villain, only to Scorpion. Throughout my history with comics and superheroes, he slowly fell down the ladder until 2004. The performance of Alfred Molina in Spider-Man 2 propelled Doc Ock back up the list. Molina brought such depth to the character that it was impossible not to like him. Many mediums have not given Octopus justice, but, like Hobgoblin, if he is given the right story, he could easily top Norman Osborn

2 - Electro
Electro is another favourite from the 60's Spider-Man show. I didn't like that he wasn't in the 1994 show. Apparently James Cameron's Spider-Man had him and Sandman as the villains so they were locked up. Nonetheless, I also very much enjoyed the Playstation game Spider-Man 2: Enter Electro. He had a great showing in Web of Shadows also. In Amazing Spider-Man 2, he is being played by Academy Award winning actor Jamie Foxx. A lot of people are complaining about Electro being played by a black actor, but I do not see the issue with it. Foxx is, credential-wise, the best actor ever cast as a comic book villain (besides maybe Tommy Lee Jones). Comic fans should just be happy that he is not being played by some pro wrestler like Bane and Sabretooth were, or played very campy like the Riddler and Two-Face were.

1 - Norman Osborn
Was there ever any doubt? Norman Osborn is lie Spider-Man's Joker, the antithesis to everything Spider-Man believes in. He also has a cool look, plenty of gadgets, and is a super soldier. He also did the ultimate evil in comic books by killing Spidey's first squeeze Gwen Stacey. Like Dr. Octopus and Venom, he has appeared in a lot of Spider-Man media, although my favourite depiction of him is in the 2002 film with Willem Dafoe. I wasn't a fan of the costume, but Dafoe's manic performace helped to put the character over. Rumor has it that Stormin' Norman will be making an appearance in the Marc Webb saga (and depending on who you want to believe, already has in the form of Michael Masse) and I hope that his version of the Goblin does this amazing character justice.

A Blockbuster vs. A Great Film

A Blockbuster vs. a Great Film

A Blog by

Mitchell A. Quondam

Blockbuster:
Released during the summer
Is hyped all year
Trailers feature mainly explosions and action scenes
Less emphasis on story & writing
Big this summer, but forgotten about by next summer

Examples of Blockbusters
Transformers 1-3
Independence Day
Godzilla 1998
GI Joe: Rise of the Cobra
The A-Team 2010
Some of the Harry Potter films
The Hurt Locker (won an Oscar, then just vanished)
Terminator Salvation
Phantom Menace
Avengers (beginning to show its holes)
Sam Raimi Spider-Man Trilogy


Great Film
Well written, by someone who can write intense dialogue
Emotionally investing film, with a story people will remember
Uniqueness, not just the typical blockbuster action film
Good actors, not models, “tough guys” or athletes/pro wrestlers pretending to act
Characters with depth
Memorable lines
Will be remembered and re-watched for years

Examples of Great Films
Toy Story 1-3
Dark Knight (Dark Knight Rises is still on the fence for me)
Titanic
Lord of the Rings Trilogy
Empire Strikes Back
Avatar (Although it is on the fence for sure)
Jurassic Park 1
Terminator 2
The Godfather 1&2
Pulp Fiction

What Makes a Good Film?

What Makes a Good Film?

A Blog by

Mitchell A. Quondam

Firstly, when I say “good,” I mean critically well, one that people go back to and enjoy watching over and over again. There is a distinct difference between a movie being financially successful and one that is critically acclaimed.

As an example, let’s look at Transformers 3. The film was panned by critics and is considered a critical flop, and yet it is the 5th highest grossing film of all time. This is because there was hype for the movie, and it seemed cool at the time, but behind all the special effects and explosions, was a weak script with unlikable characters and moments that were supposed to be funny falling flat.

Now, compare Transformers 3 to the Shawshank Redemption, currently #1 on the Internet Movie Database’s top 250 films of all time. Financially, Shawshank didn't make back what it cost when it was in theaters  but people did love it. The dialogue worked, it had an investing story, and, although it didn’t have to, it ended the film on a high note as a bonus. The issue is that, compared to giant robots and explosions, a movie that takes place in a 1940s prison doesn't look all that appealing in trailers.

This is not to say that a critically acclaimed motion picture can not have explosive action. The Terminator 2: Judgment Day is proof of this. Both a critical success as well as a financial one, James Cameron proved that action movies can have a story, which he proved again on Avatar, the highest grossing film of all time. Although many consider Avatar’s plot cliché, it still had one and was well written, complimenting its visual style ably.

What truly makes a good film is 3 things, the writing, the acting, and the directing.

Writing is maybe the most important. The story needs to both carry the plot and incite emotion from the audience. As someone who frequents the theaters  I have seen good and bad examples of this. In Transformers 2, when we are lead to believe that Shia Lebouf died, nobody cared, because his character was uninteresting and weak. However, jump foreword 3 years to the Dark Knight Rises, and people were literally crying when SPOILER ALERT! TURN BACK! Batman flies off towing a nuclear bomb and seemingly dies, which moves right into the next topic: the acting.

Christian Bale brought a lot of humanity to the very unrealistic Batman character. He built a character that people could relate to, (and I give director Christopher Nolan a lot of credit for this too) and got people emotionally invested in Batman’s story, as ridiculous as it is. It takes a certain kind of actor to play a role like that, especially considering that half the time his face is covered, so he has to act a lot with his eyes, and voice.

Lastly, the director is important. I could write an entire essay on what Michael Bay does wrong, but I’ll sum it up to this: he makes financially successful films. He builds up hype for his films by producing trailers showing off his action scenes and then people flock to see his films, but besides those action scenes, the story and acting is weak. Christopher Nolan makes people flock to see him because people know that he is a good director and won’t disappoint them. He could put out a teaser that just says “Inception: A Christopher Nolan film” and people would be excited months in advance.